Skip to main content Skip to main navigation menu Skip to site footer

Authenticity From Below: The Ethnographic Gift of Ambiguity

By Ikaika Ramones

HTML PDF
Cite As:
Ramones, Ikaika. 2026. “Authenticity From Below: The Ethnographic Gift of Ambiguity.” Cultural Anthropology 41, no. 4: 971–993. https://doi.org/10.14506/ca41.4.13.

Abstract

Authenticity is a pressing issue for any group attempting to maintain distinctiveness in contexts of change, domination, or assimilation. For Indigenous communities in particular, authenticity carries the colonial mantle of codifying what constitutes legitimate “tradition,” leading scholars to instead reject the concept. However, authenticity constitutes an urgent question on the ground. This article argues for radically re-engaging authenticity from below. Focusing on social institutions of chieftainship and mana in a Native Hawaiian royal estate organization, this article examines how actors exercised a restrained recognition of authentic continuity alongside constrained criticisms of ruptured inauthenticity. In a broader shared field, actors identified and operationalized other loci of undisputed authenticity. Directly confronting authenticity, I offer the “ethnographic gift of ambiguity,” locating actors’ ease in holding in/authenticity as each acted on the other in a dynamic unity, at once including both itself and its opposite, and mediated by practice. Authenticity is itself an Indigenous form of discernment and action, recalibrated as a practice of maintained ambiguity.

Keywords

Indigeneity; authenticity; tradition; chieftainship; mana; Hawaiʻi

Copyright

Copyright (c) 2026 Ikaika Ramones Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.